this post was submitted on 03 Oct 2024
36 points (100.0% liked)
commrequest
1515 readers
2 users here now
Community and moderator requests and nominations for unmodded communities.
No bulk requests. That means one comm request per post. This is so we can sort out their interest individually.
Community request posts with enough upbears and a volunteer for moderation willing to submit an application will be created during mod drives.
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Two points:
Esperanto is extremely Eurocentric and white in nature and in history. It seems to be a dying community and not all that useful. I’d much rather have a toki pona community and we could all learn that together.
I’m pretty sure there is an Esperanto instance which I would support federation with.
There's already [email protected], but really I do agree that Toki Pona is the better or at least more interesting language to promote, even though treating TP as an IAL is sort of a square peg through a round hole. I've even brought up the idea of adding sitelen pona as Hexbear emojis such that we can write with them.
Extremely Eurocentric, yes — it doesn't even have much of any Slavic vocabulary despite Zamenhof being a native of Białystok — but I'd question how strictly "white" Esperanto is. I've recently shared a Congolese band as well as a Sri Lankan artist who make music in Esperanto; Prolewiki's article on Esperanto talks about a declaration made by Korean Esperantists in the Chosun Ilbo in the 1920s stating that Esperanto should be used to combat Japanese linguistic imperialism.
Now you can of course question whether it is wise of those Congolese musicians to so enthusiastically support such a Eurocentric language as the world language, you can question whether that Sri Lankan artist should think of Esperanto as having a "romantic sound" if this might play into the prestige of Western European natlangs, you can question the choices of those Korean anti-imperialists, but the fact of the matter remains that Esperanto does indeed have plenty of non-white history if you actually bother to look for it. Just because Esperanto is Eurocentric in its design, and originated and first proliferated in Europe, doesn't mean that non-Europeans can't engage with the language on their own terms, whether that be from a finvenkist or a Raumist perspective.
I don't get the impression that the Esperanto community is dying at all, and I don't think the decision to learn Esperanto should be guided by the language's "usefulness" or its chances of achieving its original goal of becoming the world's second language. Esperantujo is an interesting country with an interesting history, and I think that's something that's worth preserving, regardless of how big the community is or indeed how white the community is. There are today native speakers of Esperanto whose parents were native speakers, and that's just kinda cool, right?
All great points. Thank you!