this post was submitted on 28 Sep 2023
179 points (100.0% liked)

ama

19571 readers
1 users here now

Welcome to /c/AmA

Want a scheduled AMA announced ahead of time? Contact Awoo directly at the bottom of this sidebar.

Please stick to one of either three post types:

A standard Ask Me Anything post.

A request post -- (What is the format and why should I make a request post?)

A gauging interest post -- (What is this?)

What is an AmA?

AmA’s or “Ask Me Anything” began on the old internet, originally AOL chatrooms, later followed by Slashdot. They are crowdsourced interviews where the interviewee first makes a post describing who they are and what they do. Commenters then leave questions and can vote on other questions according to which they would like to see answered.

The interviewee can then go through and reply to the questions they find interesting, and easily see those questions the internet is dying to have the answer too. Questions will be a mixture of radical, serious and lighthearted resulting in the kind of interview you won’t get elsewhere.

What Topics Are Allowed?

Anyone can do an Ask Me Anything. The topic of the AmA must meet the rules below, and in some cases you must provide proof of the claims you are making. Ask Me Anything topics fall into two categories:

Something that plays a central role in your life. The prime example of this is a person's job; posts about someone's occupation are almost always allowed. A person's topic should be something that they know thoroughly and is important to them; this gives them more to discuss and a more thorough background in the field.

A truly interesting and unique event. An example would be "I organised a protest against x." It's an activity that doesn't play a central role in someone's life but is so uncommon that many users would not have experiences of their own to relate to it.

AmAs should NOT be about:

Mutual-Aid and Crowd Funding - AmA submitters that include any aid or funding campaign must be eligible for an AmA without the campaign for it to be allowed. Additionally, the focus of the AmA must not be the campaign -- those posts would be more appropriate in the mutual-aid community. Posts about suicide.

Other Restrictions:

Giveaways are not permitted on AmA. Contests and giveaways already running on a third party site prior to the AmA are acceptable

Proof

Proof in the case of public figures or orgs may be a social media post on an official account. For other topics it may be a proof image. This does not always have to be included in the post at the time of posting and it may be discussed with the moderators and provided privately. We will ALWAYS respect your complete privacy.

founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
 

EDIT: JT has now finished. Thank you all for coming. The thread will remain open for chats to finish then we'll be locking it for preservation at some point after 24 hours. Thank you JT for joining us!

JT will be answering questions below, due to a scheduled appointment that couldn't be changed he will be starting a little late, answers will begin roughly 1 hour after the post starts.

Like usual there are no strict time limits set for this so JT will come and go as and when his time allows, if he doesn't get to your questions be patient! This post will be edited here when things end.

JT's posting account for AMAs is: @Secondthought_JT .

Be sure to check out The Deprogram if you haven't already! Available wherever you listen to podcasts.


The Deprogram | Second Thought | First Thought

The Deprogram on Twitter | JT on Twitter

The Deprogram subreddit

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [email protected] 38 points 11 months ago (4 children)

I love The Deprogram podcast, have been listening since the beginning, and was a subscriber to all 3 respective youtube channels long before the podcast started. One thing that has kinda irked me to put it mildly, is that you guys sure do talk about food a lot. That in and of itself is no problem, but whenever it comes up, it's invariably talk about how great certain fast food chains are and specifically how tasty the animal meat they killed and commodified is, which to some of your vegan fans is disappointing and even legit nauseating at times. I know to most it's just humorous chitchat about something the three of you enjoy, and I get it, but I also know I'm not the only listener really put off by it.

I wouldn't presume to tell anyone what to talk about on their own podcast, but as a listener, I find myself consistently wishing you would seriously address leftist arguments for veganism and recognize the intersectional nature of socialism and non-human animal welfare. I remember Yugopnik saying some really positive things about veganism briefly in one of the livestreams (I can't find which one now) when asked about it but then shortly after, in a regular episode he's going off about how yummy veal is and even forgetting what animal it's made from. stalin-stressed

Do you think you could ever get some vegan comrades on the show to take you to task for your unexamined carnism? lol

I want to add, more for some of the readers than for JT. Since someone always says the thought terminating cliche, I realize there is no ethical consumption under capitalism, but most leftists recognize there is a spectrum.

[–] [email protected] 50 points 11 months ago (3 children)

Ehhh yeah, I understand what you're coming from, but as bad as it sounds it's just not as pressing an issue as the liberation of humanity. I'm sure we'll have someone on at some point, but only if we can find someone who won't make our audience feel attacked for not being able to afford plant-based alternatives. We have listeners from all over the world and from all sorts of different backgrounds, and while I think all of us can agree that animal rights are important, not everyone is able to live that lifestyle

[–] [email protected] 23 points 11 months ago

There's a huge difference between telling everyone regardless of their circumstances that they need to "live that lifestyle" and recognizing how problematic your advocacy of the opposite of "that lifestyle" is on a show where you have significant influence. The constant unironic stanning of Chic Fillet and Mcdonalds and drooling over chicken tendies, all without any examination is why I stopped my patreon support and eventually stopped listening.

[–] [email protected] 20 points 11 months ago

only if we can find someone who won't make our audience feel attacked for not being able to afford plant-based alternatives.

Because absolutely none of your audience is vegan, huh?

Because plant-based alternatives are universally more expensive, huh?

Because informing people of the extreme harm that carnism causes and even how it impedes human social justice means they will feel attacked, huh?

Because all of those socialist vegans are always keen on attacking people, it's almost impossible to find ones who go out of their way to be kind and understanding, huh?

it's just not as pressing an issue as the liberation of humanity

I really hate it when people are so certain of what is the most pressing issue. Like when people say a socialist revolution in the imperial core is more pressing than addressing racism there. Or those who say getting free healthcare is more pressing than stopping the exploitation of the global south. The people who say it always do so not to advocate for the thing they feel is the most pressing issue (and that's not to say it isn't a pressing issue), they say it to disparage the importance of another issue. Different issues can be addressed simultaneously, believe it or not. We don't need to bring about the liberation of the entirety of humanity before we can start working to end the suffering of other sentient life that happens on an unimaginable scale, in large part thanks to capitalism. Not only can we work towards both at the same time, both goals are better served by doing so. That's the nature of intersectionality.

Your response is really telling, comrade.

[–] [email protected] 15 points 11 months ago

You can, so if you feel it's important then why are you eating the teddies?