I followed this guide and have not had any issues since. guide
this post was submitted on 19 Jul 2023
1 points (100.0% liked)
eero
187 readers
1 users here now
A place to have discussions, ask for help, and share new ideas related to the eero mesh Wi-Fi system.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Are you seeing all of your devices as clients in the Pihole app?
Yes, I see their ips under active clients.
Ok—that is an excellent sanity check. Thanks for confirming.
The only difference for my setup is that I have enabled HomeKit support in the eero. Never thought twice about it, but looks like it works in part by forcing dns onto the gateway router. I’ll be turning it off now.
https://community.eero.com/t/y4ht25q/separate-dns-settings-for-non-homekit-devices
https://talk.macpowerusers.com/t/for-eero-users-did-you-bother-setting-up-the-homekit/20629/2
Ok—that is an excellent sanity check. Thanks for confirming.
The only difference for my setup is that I have enabled HomeKit support in the eero. Never thought twice about it, but looks like it works in part by forcing dns onto the gateway router. I’ll be turning it off now.
https://community.eero.com/t/y4ht25q/separate-dns-settings-for-non-homekit-devices
https://talk.macpowerusers.com/t/for-eero-users-did-you-bother-setting-up-the-homekit/20629/2
Did that do anything for you? I'm looking at that guide and the only difference I see (besides the Homekit Router support which it doesn't mention) is that rather than give my piholes IP reservations in the eero app, I gave them static IPs outside of the DHCP lease range on the eero.
Yep—disabling HomeKit did the trick and I see all my clients in Pihole now. It’s funny that never occurred to me.
The only problem I have is that I can’t seem to get the client name from the eero. So I just have the IP addresses of the clients in pihole.
Interesting. It has never occurred to me either. Seeing as how newer eeros don't have the option and it looks like even Apple isn't really supporting it anymore, I might disable that too.
Ah. I’ve got 5s. Didn’t realize it was abandoned tech, so I feel even better about it. I’ll just have to start taking more softly around my lightbulbs.
Make sure you configured the Eero (in the app) to point your DHCP clients to your PiHole. On the iOS version that setting is under settings—network settings—DNS. Set it up as a custom DNS server. Then release/renew the client devices (or restart) for the setting to take effect.
Yeah that’s all set up and it’s obvious that Pihole is receiving requests from the clients. It’s just that they all appear to be from the eero gateway.
Not sure if your eero can do this easily but you probably want to use DHCP option 6 so your router will forward the DNS server you select to all clients. That's how I do it on openwrt.