BeardTube

364 readers
1 users here now

BeardTube is a place for sharing videos from a revolutionary perspective. Politics, Economics, History, Philosophy, Science, Journalism, Culture, News, Critiques, and more are welcome here as long as submitted content is relevant and of high quality. Supporting established content creators and promoting new ones is encouraged to help spread class consciousness across the internet and beyond!

founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
26
27
28
29
 
 

I am sharing this here for anybody who may be curious. The following message is from an e‐mail that Prof. Furr recently sent to me:

Dear friends:

Mr. Tristan Pennell interviewed me on Tuesday, April 26 (2022) concerning my research on Joseph Stalin and the falsehoods and lies of Stalin-era scholarship. […]

He posed five questions about Stalin and Stalin-era research. The interview is 2 hours in length.

In case you'd prefer to listen to it in sections, I have marked the times where a new question and answer begins..


Here are the questions Mr. Pennell chose to ask me.

Start (my answer begins at 1:35) - Stalin’s coming to power & the subsequent conspiracies/attempts to remove him with forgeries of Lenin’s writings

10:58 - The reality of collectivization - how it was actually a real reform that led to a dramatic bettering of living conditions for the peasantry, food security for the country, and also allowed for rapid industrialization.

22:29 - Trotsky being exiled, Yezhovshchina (mainly how it wasn’t Stalin’s “terror” but a plot to stir up discontent between the people & the party) and how the Stalin leadership eventually caught and crushed this plot.

32:41 - The truth about the Purges and how it wasn’t Stalin removing his political opponents as the anti-communists say, but actual threats to the country.

1:09:47 - The next topic is one I think is important, & that is the democratic legacy of Stalin. His anti-bureaucracy/pro-democracy movement, his work on the 1936 constitution & how even without having everything Stalin wanted, it still nonetheless was the most democratic constitution in the world.


I would appreciate any criticisms or other comments you might care to make. Good, intelligent criticism can only help me improve my research.

30
31
32
33
 
 

video debunking class collaborative "representation" as a path towards real change

34
35
36
37
38
39
 
 

Video is about an hour long (around 58 minutes).

40
41
42
 
 

I looked at his activity on the same day as the tweet and I reckon he is talking about tendencies like this in the subreddit.

Just wanted to say that that sub is pretty garbage. And I tend to avoid it like the black plague. But it's nice to see that a non-ML YouTuber doesn't hesitate in praising existing socialist countries. The usual behaviour is to shy away from this to cater to the anarchildren audience.

43
 
 

Video is:

29:35

44
 
 

Listening to Comrade Elishuva right now.

45
 
 

Duration: 57:36

46
 
 

I'm thinking of rebooting my YouTube channel.

However, I don't know if I should have a Patreon or IndieGoGo or what.

I'm pretty strapped for cash and I'm only now getting a job after some time (a pretty good one, it seems, too).

But all the same: I'm pretty much poor.

Should I leave a place where people can make donations to me? I'm trying to be financially secure.

Not that I wouldn't do the video channel for other reasons, but I feel that I don't have much of a choice.

Is it okay?

47
48
49
50
 
 

Best talk I've ever heard.

view more: ‹ prev next ›