this post was submitted on 29 Oct 2024
43 points (97.8% liked)
Books
4451 readers
30 users here now
A community for all things related to Books.
Rules
- Be Nice
Official Bingo Posts:
Related Communities
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I'm currently reading the first book of the 3 body problem series. Still trying to decide if I like it or not even though I'm almost done with it.
I read the entire trilogy a couple of years ago and I'll say a couple of things about it: the big ideas are great and the plot is interesting but the characters and the actual mechanics of the writing are solidly mediocre at times. I'm not sure if that's down to the translation between languages (Ken Liu's two translations are much better than the middle book IMO) or just the style of the novels but it's definitely a pain point for the series.
Parts of the later books read like bad western SF from the 60s or 70s and some of the later themes are ridiculously reactionary. Like women being incapable of aggressive choices necessary for survival or the decadent feminized men who are incapable of things in general. There's some large scale human social critique involved later about societal wishful thinking that's 100% on point but I won't spoil that for you.
It's definitely worth reading, pieces of the trilogy are great, but it also goes in decidedly reactionary directions at times as well. It's sort of like reading Ringworld - lots of neat concepts with some chauvinistic social commentary.
Holy shit! Me too, except I've decided I like it. It is a compelling story. It goes a bit hard on the scientific accuracy which can kind of interrupt the flow, though.
I find the most interesting part is the insight of modern Chinese commentary of recent Chinese history. I wasn't sure what popular sentiment was, or what criticism / critiques would be allowed to be published by the party.
I've read the English translations of the trilogy. If you like mystery, high-concept sci-fi, and epic storytelling, the series is pretty terrific. But if your into rounded and compelling characters, especially if those characters are women, your going to have a bad time.
Kinda reminds me of classic authors like Heinlein.
Heinlein or Niven are pretty accurate comparisons IMO
I've never read anything by Heinlein, is there a particular book you would recommend?
Been wanting to read this, but I'm halfway through book 7 of 8 of the witcher series, and I don't want to leave the series undone before switching to the next book. The witcher series has been great, but this book is getting slow and hard to finish.
I finally got bored enough on a plane to watch the 3 body problem TV show. Based on liking the TV show, I'm hoping I'm gonna like the book too.
Ah, I set the Witcher books down halfway through but gotta get back to them! Glad to hear you're enjoying them. At least they're mostly short-ish.
They've been pretty fun reads so far, but this 7th book has been a bit of a slog. I think I finally got over some of the more boring parts last night, so hoping the rest of the book is easier to finish.
I watched half of the first episode before it was mentioned to me that there were already elements of the second book there. To keep me interested in the tv show, I decided to read the books first but I'm glad to hear you enjoyed it.