this post was submitted on 03 Sep 2023
19 points (88.0% liked)

One Piece

537 readers
9 users here now

Discussion of all Grand Line stuff, fanart and theories regarding Eiichiro Oda's anime One Piece.

Rules:

  1. Topic: Posts must be related to One Piece
  2. Tags: Lemmy doesn’t have tags yet, so please mark posts with [Episode/Chapter], [Fanart], [Question], [Discussion], [Theory] or others you may think are appropriate. e.g. [Theory, ep1/ch1]: this guy with the hat will be pirate king!
  3. Spoilers: No spoilers in titles, tag posts containing spoilers as such!
  4. Behavior: No spam, personal attacks, racism, sexism and any other discrimination (in short: don't be a jerk in any way - Code of Conduct).
  5. Spam: Please do not spam
  6. NSFW: Please refrain from posting NSFW/Hentai content

Please DM the mod(s) if you see violations that are not handled in time.

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
[email protected]
19
So, are you guys watching the live action? (feddit.it)
submitted 11 months ago by [email protected] to c/[email protected]
8 comments fedilink hide all child comments
 

And most importantly, what do you think about it? I think it's quite bad except for a few nice details and while being definitely shorter it also feels like it's missing some of the features that make OP such a quintessential read. Nonetheless, still amusing lol

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [email protected] 14 points 11 months ago

As someone who's watched all the anime and read all the manga from the beginning, I've been watching the live action and so far really enjoying it.

No, the plot is not entirely accurate, the characters aren't 100% the same, but honestly I wouldn't want them to be. The One Piece manga and anime just wouldn't translate 100% to live action and be a good show. I think the adaptation and the changes they make work very well for a live action show (without spoiling anything).

The things they needed to get right, they did, IMO. For example, Luffy's pure optimism, the relationship within the straw hat crew, the emotional scenes (I cried a few times)...

A lot of people expect and want to see a 100% faithful adaptation, but that doesn't make sense to me. If I wanted to watch/read One Piece, I would just watch the anime or read the manga. As a OP fan, the live action serves a specific purpose for me which is just to relive some of the moments I watched as a kid with real people and to see different take on the story. I think the show achieved that.