- New South Wales police have identified a 40-year-old man who fatally stabbed six people and critically injured at least 12 others at Sydney's Westfield Bondi Junction mall on Saturday before he was shot and killed by a senior police officer. NSW Police Public Site
- According to law enforcement, the assailant — Joel Cauchi — belonged to the northeastern Australian state of Queensland, had been recently sleeping in his car, and was known to the Queensland police. However, he was never arrested or charged with any crimes. Reuters (LR: 3 CP: 5)
- New South Wales Police Commissioner Karen Webb ruled out terrorism or "ideological motivation," adding that a probe has been launched to determine why Cauchi singled out women. BBC News (LR: 3 CP: 5)
- Joel's father, Andrew Cauchi, described his son as a "very sick boy" suffering from schizophrenia, claiming he may have targeted women because he "wanted a girlfriend" – alleging he had "no social skills," and that he was "frustrated out of his brain." Associated Press (LR: 3 CP: 5)
- Joel's victims included Dawn Singleton (25), Jade Young (47), Ashlee Good (38), Pikria Darchia (55), and Yixuan Cheng (25) — all women. The only man killed was Faraz Tahir (30), a Pakistani refugee who worked at the mall as a security guard. 9
- Out of the 12 victims who survived their injuries – including Good's nine-month-old baby – eight remained in hospital on Monday. ABC News
Narrative A:
- Saturday's tragedy could have been avoided if only the attacker's mental health was taken seriously — both by his family and law enforcement. Despite having a chronic brain disorder, Joel had access to combat knives. He was known to the Queensland police, yet his activities weren't monitored. Innocent people have paid with their lives for a man driven by mental illness.
VOICE OF AMERICA
Narrative B:
- Saturday's stabbing wouldn't have taken place if the mall's security guard had been armed. Blaming a mentally ill person squarely for a massacre is a distraction from government negligence and responsibility. Joel needed help, which he was denied. Now that he is deceased, he has been blamed for law enforcement's failure to prevent a horrific tragedy.
CNN (LR: 2 CP: 5)
Narrative C:
- This horrific act of violence, Australia's deadliest in at least eight years, has stunned and horrified a country where mass killings are rare. Joel has been punished for indiscriminately targeting innocent shoppers. It's paramount to thank the police and emergency services for their bravery in the face of this shocking incident and support the families of victims and eyewitnesses in these grim times.
BBC NEWS (LR: 3 CP: 5)
Narrative D:
- There's no doubt that mass casualty events are rare in Australia. However, Saturday's attack should kick off another national debate about gun control. As Australians who already own guns have bought more, and there's an increase in new gun owners since Canberra implemented one of the world's toughest gun laws more than two decades ago, Joel’s horrific crimes serve as a warning against complacency.
THE UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY