Hey thanks for the tip! I also felt like fediverse was being suppressed by google, but wasn't sure whether thats the case or does google just need time to properly index these sites.
this post was submitted on 15 Jun 2023
172 points (100.0% liked)
Reddit Migration
84 readers
1 users here now
### About Community Tracking and helping #redditmigration to Kbin and the Fediverse. Say hello to the decentralized and open future. To see latest reeddit blackout info, see here: https://reddark.untone.uk/
founded 1 year ago
I think that's part of it, but Lemmy has been around for as long as Tildes so it doesn't really add up. Tbh this was my main issue so now I don't have a good reason to go back to Reddit ever.
It the other way around: kbin.social explicitly does not allow indexing by search engines. If DuckDuckGo ignores this default, the fault is basically not with Google.
Why?
Because it puts a considerable strain on Kbin’s servers, because there is a lot of content to crawl.
I suspect (hope, even) that if Kbin runs on beefier hardware some time in the future, crawling can be enabled. However, since Kbin is completely free and devoid of ads, we would probably need to start a donation drive to make that happen.
Theres a buymeacoffee.com link in the About section at the bottom of the page.
I wouldn't even be opposed to awards to fund stuff, although I could see the slippery slope of money 😞
Agreed. Indexing helps a LOT for discovery both of new content and old answers alike ... Would love to see kbin start showing up in search results instead of Reddit when trying to find answers to technical issues...
Ah, makes sense. I seems like 90% of the Fediverse's problems revolve around size limits. I feel bad for Ernest having to deal with all of this himself.
To be a suitable replacement for Reddit, it's going to have to allow it at some point. Everyone knows the way to find anything now is to add "reddit" to the search term in google now.
Alternatively, a custom indexer for the fediverse could be set up. That would be a lot more efficient in teens of network traffic for everyone involved, and the search engine wouldn't rely on a specific instance (kbin in this case) to have complete and accurate data.
So in order every single Fediverse instances, I'd have to include all of them? It'll be more fun if something that can exist to globally search every instances (and give us filter to opt out of some that the user do not enjoy) instead of making it a long long string like site:kbin.social + site:lemmy.world... Like kind of how greasyfork is doing with their search engine, I like it.
Cool! I added this URL as a bookmark: https://www.google.com/search?q=(site%3Akbin.social+OR+site%3Alemmy.world+OR+site%3Ash.itjust.works+OR+site%3Abeehaw.org+OR+site%3Alemmy.ml+OR+site%3Alemmy.ca+OR+site%3Amidwest.social+OR+site%3Alemmy.blahaj.zone).
Now I can click it and add anything in the front of the search to find things across the entire reddit-like fediverse. I tried the same with DuckDuckGo and it didn't really work? Might need different formatting.
@slicedcheesegremlin
Mastodon users have the option to opt-out of search engines indexing by adding tags to their post hat are readable by web crawlers.
So you might not find everything from mastodon, but for a reddit-like it makes sense to be indexed.
Assuming crawlers actually respect it. I've had to IP ban some crawlers because they didn't.
That makes sense, thanks.
Since nobody has mentioned them in this thread, you should know that there are search sites for Lemmy communities.
https://lemmyverse.net/communities
https://browse.feddit.de/