Wait is Dobbi the real hero of Harry Potter?
this post was submitted on 18 Nov 2024
516 points (99.0% liked)
Lord of the memes
8157 readers
477 users here now
The Lord of the rings memes communitiy on Lemmy. Share memes about Lord of the rings and be respectful.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
The house elves yearning for subjugation means that Dobbi is likely seen as a villain
Yeah, I always have a tough time telling if Kreacher was an Uncle Ruckus or if Dobby was a traitor and deviant to his people.
Like, we think of it as Dobby (or any House Elf) being released from slavery, but I wonder if it is more like being a Ronin.
It's supposed to be a commentary on internalized racism and cultural inertia but, because Rowling is a bit of a goof, she made it sound like racial essentialism instead.
Hermione and Dobby are not the weirdos, society is.
Master gave us a ring!
It was forged by a being that was super old and didn't have any death on the horizon like mortals have, and had cruelty, malice, and a will to dominate all life poured into it ~~by another nearly-immortal being~~. It sat for two and a half thousand years doing diddly squat, passing out of all knowledge.
My point is, it's patient.
What's 500 years when compared with eternity?
Maybe I'm reading this wrong, but it sounds like you're saying Celebrimbor forged the one ring, and Sauron poured his malice into it. That's incorrect: the one was Sauron's creation, which he made using the knowledge he gained from assisting in the forging of the seven and the nine.
Brain fart! You are correct, I was thinking Celebrimbor forged the One Ring with Sauron.
Guess that just mean it's time to reread. Oh noooooooooo
Came here to ask about this, I should have figured someone would have already given an explanation in the comments.
Not sure if it's accurate but I assume the hobbits' resistance to the ring's power might have slowed this down too.
One Ring has ADHD.