Comradeship // Freechat

It's a good show. I just finished it. As for the politics of it, the show isn't Marxist despite its anger at the super rich.

The show makes a number of mistakes in its analysis of the world. Firstly, it acts as though the problems of Capitalism began in the 1980s. We know that Capitalism has always been horrific. The show also falls for the Great Men Fallacy. At one point we see all of the the bad, rich people who run the world in a room together. Capitalism is more pervasive than that. The guy who owns a fast-food franchise is just as much a Capitalist as a CEO. These mistakes work for the themes of the show, however. It is a show about hacking and conspiracies. In reality, a group of super hackers can't expose the big bads who rule the world and steal their money, but it does make for an entertaining show.

Its great, but dont fixate too much on the anti-capitalism vibes, its more of a character driven show

How far are you? By season 3 I found the main character's resistance to actually resisting capitalism was becoming annoying.

Starts really good and gets worse as it goes on

It's quite good. The first piece of content to show the hacking/computer world accurately.

Rami Malek does a stellar job.

It is mostly radlib anti-capitalism, and there is a huge recession and a lot of bailouts for E-Corp after their heist. So, I believe that it is season 2 and 3 where several characters are starting to say things like "maybe overthrowing capitalism and revolution are misguided". But if you just want a character based drama with a lot of twists, it is not bad.

Okay, first my honest review is it's one of my favorite shows I've ever watched. It portrays hacking relatively well. It portrays Anxiety and mental issues fairly well for a show. And it's a fantastic execution of the unreliable narrator. If you haven't heard of the unreliable narrator, then go look up the trope so you get the gist of what's going on.

Now for my full disclosure I fell in love with the show before becoming a Marxist. So this has absolutely nothing to do with my Marxist identity now.

Yeah, it's pretty anti-capitalist, and they use the term "revolution" a lot. But it's kind of a bougie revolution, like an anti-technocrat thing.

I wouldn't watch it for any marxist vibes, but in the end I still heavily recommend the show. Even as Marxists can enjoy some regular old TV shows and this was one of the highest claimed and most well-rewarded shows on TV when it came out.

All of that being said, the first season is the best season. I do think it gets a little bit hard to track over time, but the creator of the show built the entire series to be one fluid storyline from the beginning. So I think it's worth finishing. You will literally learn things in the very last season that will affect the first episodes that you're watching right now. I'm not trying to spoil it, but I am trying to get you excited to watch the whole thing. I had to watch the entire series twice to truly come to my understanding of the show and what it really means.

Not to spoil it, but it starts out very strong but the political quality goes down exponentially over time after the first season. I couldn't bring myself to finish the last season because I was pretty bored.

I watched the first two episodes and I realized oh, it's one of those shows. The ones where everyone is an asshole for no reason and they do shit nobody would ever do because we have to show how big of an asshole they are. That's what makes it mature and gritty.

I watched the whole thing. I liked it a lot. It hits like an anarchist fantasy (in the best possible way).

There's a heavy bend towards hyper-violence later on in the show. I was invested in the characters and the storytelling at that point, but it was really difficult to watch.

Honestly, just watch season 1 and then bail. Mac Quayle's soundtrack was phenomenal throughout, though. Do yourself a favour and listen to all of it.

Honestly, there's probably some fanfic written by leftists out there that picks up after S1 and does everything better.

The first few seasons are great. The 4th season is a bit of a mess. First it was cancelled, and later renewed, if I remember correctly.

Yes, one of best TV series I saw, I miss it much

Dark army = typical racist bullshit stereotypes.

Loved the series. >!Things get pretty dark and somewhat boring in the later seasons !<

I have never heard of it until now

I started it last year, got halfway through Season 1 then became too busy to continue. will probably pick it up again at some point

It s a good show, well produced and acted. The writing is better than a majority of TV shows. It has ups and downs in the quality as all shows do but its worth watching the whole thing. I've watched the whole thing a couple times and depending on how quickly my slop trough fills I may watch it again in the next couple years.

Its not Marxist. Its "proto-left" liberal daydreaming but that is better than the majority of slop available. I'd say it pipelines towards leftist ideas without ever saying anything directly leftist.