NineSwords

joined 6 months ago
MODERATOR OF
[–] [email protected] 2 points 2 hours ago* (last edited 2 hours ago)

My pick is more general: Fan Service. As in scene that are forced in for the sole purpose to have some ecchi scenes with the cast. It works in anime, but not in novel form. At least in anime you get some sexy anime characters out of it even if it is detrimental to the story. But when you only have the story then that's it. Just a net negative.

META: Thanks @[email protected] and @I2jgwh0hYtxrCZQ @lemmy.sdf.org for picking up my slack these past two weeks. Myne has learned some new tricks over the summer vacation as well and will post the Midweek Discussion going forward. But since she is a bit preoccupied with all that's happening in Yurgenschmidt at the moment she still could use some help. So if anyone has ideas for discussion topics send me (not Myne) a message and I'll add them to the pool of topics she will randomly pick one from each week.

[–] [email protected] 1 points 2 hours ago* (last edited 1 hour ago)

I actually dropped Spider? in volume 11. I always hated the human side chapters with a passion and shifting the story more and more towards their side made me lose interest in the plot entirely. And when vol 11 was almost only human side it was the breaking point for me.

the same thing happened with SlimeTensei and Yuuki and his gang. Interestingly around the same volume number. Is there something in the 11-12-13 range of volumes that makes authors discard their series premise? Like year 7 of a marriage?

Anyway, my pro-tip for authors: if your series is called Spider/Slime/Sword/BigMac/whatever then your readers are reading for the Spider/Slime/Sword/BigMac/whatever. Don't shift the focus away from what they bought your book for in the first place. It's not that hard.

[–] [email protected] 3 points 3 days ago

Read a lot this past week but didn't take long notes.

RVing My Way into Exile with My Beloved Cat: This Villainess Is Trippin’ Volume 2 - mid, but better than the first volume.

Only the Villainous Lord Wields the Power to Level Up: Volume 1-5 - entertaining but the most basic strategies are being lauded as genius masterstrokes. Like attacking a supply line is completely baffling the enemy's master tactician.

Peddler in Another World: I Can Go Back to My World Whenever I Want! Volume 8 - Cliffhanger. Not happy :(

Welcome to Japan, Ms. Elf! Volume 9 - Dragon on Dragon action. I want to see this animated.

Min-Maxing My TRPG Build in Another World: Volume 9 Canto I - As the "Canto I" indicates it's a multi part arc which means: Cliffhanger. Not happy :(. Also MC defiles best girl Margit. Extra not happy. May he always roll ones.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 1 week ago* (last edited 1 week ago)

I just wish they would release it quicker.

The release schedule is really terrible. Regularly 6 month between volumes and between 18 and 19 were 8 months. But yeah, the series is great. All my Naval Fleet in Anno 1800 is named after Death March characters.

[–] [email protected] 4 points 1 week ago

I pick Spice and Wolf. I think that was only my second light novel Light Novel I've ever read. I started reading the fan translation online after the anime was announced and I've heard people talk positively about the series. So that must be around 2007. And to this day there weren't many series that had that much depth.

[–] [email protected] 3 points 1 week ago (1 children)

The Former Assassin Who Got Reincarnated as a Noble Girl Vol.1 - Annoying MC character. I can deal with that type of stoic MC with autism but here it is glorified. As if it's something "cool" to strife for. The author also has never seen a kid. I get it that MC as a reincarnate has more adult thought patterns, but that every other 6-year-old kid around MC is also a conniving and scheming mastermind. The same goes for the illustrator. They clearly never saw a 6-year-old if that's how they draw them. Then again, maybe it's better this way.

The Trials of Chiyodaku, Vol. 1: Running the Supreme Court of Another World With My Sister - dropped 2 chapters in. Terrible.

Magic Stone Gourmet: Eating Magical Power Made Me the Strongest Volume 5 - Did not expect a spin-off to Do You Love Your Mom and Her Two-Hit Multi-Target Attacks?. And reading this made me just as uncomfortable.

Magic Stone Gourmet: Eating Magical Power Made Me the Strongest Volume 6 - Less lusting after his mother and more story. Good. That being said, I feel like the setting in this volume goes thoroughly unused. MC visits a secluded elven village and 95% of this is just about spelunking around in the dungeon-like thingy in there. No exploring this (to this world) totally unique environment. There are some hints of that on the way to the village but once there it's all "yeah, yeah, whatever.. let's go to the dungeon already". And even in there, it feels like a PUG run of an instance 2 years into a WoW expansion.

How a Realist Hero Rebuilt the Kingdom: Volume 18 - This series really isn't worth reading anymore and wasn't since 3 sentences into introducing Fuuga. I've come this far and I might even finish the series just to be done with it.

[–] [email protected] 1 points 1 week ago

It’s a slow burn for sure.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 1 week ago

The anime was cute, maybe I give romance LN another try.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 2 weeks ago (1 children)

Good questions. I'm sooo gonna steal them ;)

[–] [email protected] 2 points 2 weeks ago (2 children)

None come to mind but how many classic board game have any lore that could be used as a setting? Maybe something like Alice in Wonderland based on cards?

6
submitted 2 weeks ago* (last edited 2 weeks ago) by [email protected] to c/[email protected]
 

Let's talk about light novels adapting game scenarios this week. Otome games are by now something of a trope for light novels. But how popular are otome games really? Why does it feel like every other LN is playing in a otome game scenario when there are so many video game genres that are so much more popular. There is an argument to be had that the other half of video game related light novels is based on some fantasy (VR)MMO with basic RPG mechanics.

There are also single series that pick up some unusual game/genre like Minecraft in Survival in Another World with My Mistress or a God Sim in The NPCs in this Village Sim Game Must Be Real!. But those are outliers and I want more of stuff like that. There are enough LN about generic fantasy RPGs and otome games already. I want something fresh. Where's my Anno city/empire builder LN?

Another point for discussion: is Re:Zero a souldborne LN? Lots of death and suffering with respawns at certain points that reset the world.


Some META:

I'll be on vacation for the next two weeks and if someone has an idea for a Midweek discussion I would be glad If someone else could answer the call of duty. (Or want to post about non-Japanese LN or even fat novels but fear my vengeful wrath? This is your chance!)

I'll try to have an eye on here in those two weeks and Myne will post her two threads as usual, but whatever I'll do will be very sporadic and not in a timely fashion.

[–] [email protected] 4 points 2 weeks ago

The Water Magician: Arc 1 Volume 2 - I like the volume. There is less of that Marvel-style banter in this volume and what is there feels more natural and less forced than in the first volume. I also like the addition of some romance to the plot. I would have liked it better if it weren't the love-at-first-sight type, but at least the love interest is competent and not a damsel in distress. There are a couple of negatives though. The translation is riddled with typos and grammatical errors (stuff like "Thankfully, skeletons don’t literally blood.” or "Also in the eastern woods...well, deeper in the words, a little south." Just as examples. There are a lot of those types of errors. I hope they fix whatever is happening at Jnovel.club because the translations from them have a lot of mistakes in the last couple of months and this book was one of the worst offenders in that regard.

The Otome Heroine’s Fight for Survival: Volume 1 - Love that murder hobo brat. The rest of the story is a bit cliche so far, but it gets effortlessly carried by MC. Since I bitched about too-good-to-kill-MCs a while back I've been picking up series with ruthess MCs and little Alicia here might very well be my favorite of the bunch. Makes sense since the author seem to have the same thought about those too-good MCs. Here's a quote from the afterword:

I noticed this tendency for the protagonist to become overly merciful halfway in my other stories too, so I decided to write one who would never show her enemies any mercy at all.

nice.

The Frontier Lord Begins with Zero Subjects: Volume 4 - Okay, so there are little baby-baals and puppies now in Iluk village. Cool I guess, but: Where. The. Fuck. Are. The. Illustrations?! I want to see cute baby baals and puppies but there isn't a single illustration of the most central plot point of this volume. Not on the cover. Not in the color pages. Not in the b/w illustration mid chapter. Nowhere. In the words of my favorite goblin slayer: "Horseshit".

[–] [email protected] 1 points 2 weeks ago

Min-Maxing and Welcome to Japan, Ms. Elf! for me. That reminds me, wasn't there supposed to be an anime of this? Am I too impatient or was this scrapped?

 

What type of Afterword reader are you? I know someone who reads the afterword first and regardless of how often I tell them that they are a perverse freak and should be ashamed they are unapologetic and don't change their wicked ways.

And while we're speaking about Afterwords, have you come across interesting ones? Personally, I like ones that give some background info about the volume the most and afterwords written as the characters least.

 

I don't have much this week, but when playing around with AI last week I had it generate synopses at some point. Some of them were hilarious so for this week I just want to share some.


Ascendance of a Bookworm as a 90s forth wall breaking comedy movie:

Cue the quirky 90s synth music and flashy title card.

Meet Myne, a modern-day bookworm extraordinaire, who just had the unluckiest day ever—crushed to death by her towering book collection. Record scratch. Yup, you heard that right. But instead of the afterlife, she wakes up in the body of a frail little girl in a medieval world where books are rarer than a TV remote that actually works.

Myne looks directly at the camera, eyebrows raised. “Seriously, who writes this stuff?”

Myne's new medieval world is all about swords, sorcery, and an alarming lack of good hygiene. But for Myne, the real tragedy is the lack of books. She pulls out a parchment and quill, giving the camera a deadpan look. “This is what they call a book here. I mean, come on!”

Determined to bring the joys of literature to the masses—or at least get herself something decent to read—Myne sets off on a series of zany misadventures. From negotiating with clueless nobles to outsmarting a guild of suspicious craftsmen, she’s on a mission to revolutionize this bookless backwater.

Montage of Myne getting into all sorts of 90s-style hijinks: almost setting the village on fire with a homemade printing press, getting tangled in a huge scroll, and facepalming at the medieval methods of paper-making.

But it’s not all laughs and giggles. Myne’s got a condition called the “Devouring,” which sounds serious but mostly means she’s got to achieve her dreams before her body gives out. Talk about a deadline! Myne, with a mischievous grin, holds up a sundial. “Tick-tock, am I right?”

Along the way, she’s joined by a quirky cast of characters:

  • Lutz, the loyal sidekick with big dreams and an even bigger heart.
  • Benno, the savvy merchant who’s more interested in profits than prose.
  • Ferdinand, the stern but secretly soft-hearted priest who can't believe he's getting roped into her schemes.

Together, they bumble, stumble, and somehow manage to start a literary revolution, one hilarious mishap at a time.

Myne winks at the camera, a stack of freshly printed books in hand. “Who says you can’t judge a book by its cover?”

So, grab your popcorn and settle in for “Ascendance of a Bookworm,” the 90s comedy romp that proves even a bookworm can change the world—one page at a time.

Freeze frame on Myne holding up a book, while the rest of the cast strikes a pose around her. Roll credits.


Spice and Wolf: A Tarantino-Esque Synopsis

Welcome to the gritty, fast-talking world of "Spice and Wolf," where medieval trade meets modern swagger in a whirlwind of gold coins and razor-sharp wit. Our story kicks off with Lawrence Kraft, a sharp-dressed, smooth-talking merchant with an eye for the next big score. Enter Holo, a feisty, no-nonsense wolf goddess disguised as a sultry young woman, complete with ears and a tail that hint at her wild side.

The unlikely duo teams up in a blaze of bartering brilliance, tearing through bustling bazaars and backwater towns with a mix of charm, brains, and a little brute force when necessary. Holo’s centuries-old wisdom and wily instincts are the perfect foil to Lawrence’s street-smart hustle, creating a partnership as volatile as it is lucrative.

Their journey is a rollercoaster of high-stakes deals and dangerous liaisons, peppered with colorful characters straight out of a rogue’s gallery. From crooked guild leaders to cutthroat competitors, everyone’s out to make a quick buck or stab you in the back. Lawrence and Holo navigate this treacherous terrain with a blend of sardonic humor and ruthless efficiency, leaving a trail of broken hearts and busted heads in their wake.

Amid the chaos, sparks fly between the merchant and the wolf, their banter crackling with sexual tension and mutual respect. But beneath the surface, there’s a deeper game at play. Holo’s true nature must remain hidden, a secret that could spell their doom in a world where gods and monsters are more than just legends.

"Spice and Wolf" is a pulse-pounding, adrenaline-fueled saga where every deal could be a double-cross, and every smile hides a knife. In true Tarantino fashion, it’s a wild ride through a world where the stakes are high, the dialogue is snappy, and the heroes are anything but clean-cut. Buckle up for a tale of love, betrayal, and cold, hard cash—because in this game, it’s all or nothing.


Reincarnated as a Slime: A 70s Adult Film-Inspired Synopsis

In a world where fantasy and forbidden pleasures collide, an ordinary man meets an untimely end and is about to discover that being reborn as a slime in a magical realm opens the door to tantalizing escapades and seductive encounters.

As the slime begins to explore this new world, it encounters a cast of voluptuous and enchanting beings—each more alluring than the last. From bewitching sorceresses to fierce, curvaceous warriors, every meeting promises a blend of peril and passion. With its newfound powers, the slime shapeshifts and adapts, becoming whatever it needs to be to survive and thrive in this sensual, mystical land.

Through steamy alliances and seductive battles, the slime carves out a kingdom of its own, attracting followers with its irresistible charm and unparalleled power. Each encounter is a pulse-pounding blend of danger and desire, as the slime learns that in this world, every conquest is both a challenge and a pleasure.

 
  • Toradora!
  • Reincarnated as a Sword
  • Perfect Blue: Complete Metamorphosis
  • The Condemned Villainess Goes Back in Time and Aims to Become the Ultimate Villain
  • The Evil Queen’s Beautiful Principles
4
submitted 1 month ago* (last edited 1 month ago) by [email protected] to c/[email protected]
 

English is not my first langue and the lack of finely polished prose when crafting my reviews is the sole thing holding this community back. In order to not further subject you fine people to my peasant words, I decided to employ the help of an artificial ghostwriter to spruce up my works for this week’s Midweek Discussion. At least that was my initial course of action, but as hillarious as the results were it doesn’t leave much space open for discussion. So I decided to do start a little quiz instead. I spruce up light novel titles instead for you all to guess:

  1. "I have ascended to unparalleled strength, wielding diminutive incantations to obliterate all opposition."
  2. "The leisurely adventures of a seasoned herder, who has embarked upon her journey at an unconventional juncture in time."
  3. "Culinary Adventures: Preparing Delectable Dishes from Exotic Game Ingredients"
  4. "A Symphonic Odyssey through the Land of the Afterlife: A Tale of Perilous Travel to an Altered Universe."
  5. "Tired of this languid existence? Having been reborn as a preeminent Elven being, my current state is one of profound ennui."

This should be enough to get the guessing going. Feel free to add your own so that I get to guess as well. (prompt was simply "Rewirte the following to make it sound more eloquent: [TITLE]”)

edit: Answers:

spoiler

  1. I Became the Strongest and Annihilated Everything With Low-Level Spells (I left out the "Failure Frame” because the AI kept it unchanged)
  2. A Late-Start Tamer’s Laid-Back Life (yeah, don’t ask me where the journey in a unconventional time stuff came from)
  3. Cooking with Wild Game
  4. Death March to the Parallel World Rhapsody (love the Rhapsody turning into “Symphonic Odyssey” and thought it would be the easiest to guess because of it)
  5. Enough with This Slow Life! I Was Reincarnated as a High Elf and Now I’m Bored (Ennui is my new favorite word)
6
submitted 1 month ago* (last edited 1 month ago) by [email protected] to c/[email protected]
 

I'm running out of ideas, so this week it's a free4all.

Want to tell me how retarded your sister is? Have at it! Need to convince me that Saiki is the best Band Maid member? Already sold! Gawr Gura: gremlin or genius? Why not both! Have something cool to show off? I love seeing pictures of cool stuff.

You get the drift. Have something you always want to get off your soul, this is your chance.

 

Another week, another episode of the crowd pleaser Midweek Discussion. This time let's discuss the other half of what makes a light novel a light novel.

Most of the time I have to say that I don't really give much thought to the illustrator. I might read an LN and think, oh "That art style looks good" or "That design is interesting", but most of the time I won't even remember the name of the artist even in those cases, and if they were silently replaced I would be oblivious to it. That doesn't mean that the illustrations are irrelevant though. The art style alone has a big influence of how I perceive a text. The artwork on the cover will set the tone with which I read that novel. I will interpret a scene differently if there is a derpy artwork on the cover versus a grimdark one for example. Sure the prose can overcome the

But there are exceptions. Illustrators that I find absolutely essential to a series. You Shiina (no, not you! the illustrator /sigh) is one such example, but that's too on the nose. So I would like to point out so-bin instead. The illustrator of the Overlord series. His artwork stands out so much amongst the mass of LN illustrations. You could just get a glimpse of an Overlord illustration and immediately recognize from which series it comes.

This does not only apply to the cover illustrations but also the in-chapter illustrations as well (one more because I couldn't choose just the two examples).

TL;DR: so-bin good.

So, my questions for this week are:

  • do you have favorite illustrators and who are they?
  • how important are the illustrations to you?
  • what are good examples (I admit that's just an excuse of a question for me just wanting to see pretty pictures)
  • what would you like to see more in LN illustrations? For example, I would like to see more establishing shots instead of just key moments or character introductions.
 

Japanese publishers, including Shueisha and Shogakukan, have invested $4.9 million in Mantra, a startup leveraging AI to accelerate manga translation.

I don't read many mangas, so I don't know how good or bad the translations are, but I thought the news was interesting at least.

 

No books are allowed here this week. Tell me how you spend your free time when you're not reading.

When I'm not reading or watching anime I'm usually playing games. This used to be my main hobby but for the last several years I kinda lost interest and are now just playing in bursts whenever something catches my fancy. I'm finishing up the last bits and bobs of Shadow of the Erdtree right now and I might start Shin Megami Tensei 5: Vengeance next. Just like the non-remake version, I played it for about 30 minutes and then something else caught my eye. This time I want to pick it back up and not just forget it again, but my backlog is insane and it feels more like an obligation than something I actually want to do (which takes a lot out of the fun of the whole thing).

I also started to get into cooking for the past 5 years or so and are currently in my creative phase where I try to come up with new stuff instead of following recipes. It's not good honestly...

 

Reading through D-Genesis which is an extreme example of a LN written from multiple POVs got me thinking about this. I can't think of a single instance where I like the multiple POV type of writing. I enjoy a bonus chapter from a fresh POV well enough, but in the main body I want to follow a single protagonist and I find it tiresome to emotionally adjust to a new protagonist in short order.

What do you all think about this? Are there any LN with multiple POVs that are good?

 

Which LN has the best ad?

My pick would be Re:Zero. The first season is so well done that I had to pick up the LN to see how it continues.

view more: next ›