1.5kg under the limit, according to the FIA. That's a bunch. Major team screwup.
this post was submitted on 28 Jul 2024
135 points (97.2% liked)
Formula 1
8974 readers
82 users here now
Welcome to Formula1 @ Lemmy.world Lemmy's largest community for Formula 1 and related racing series
Rules
- Be respectful to everyone; drivers, lemmings, redditors etc
- No gambling, crypto or NFTs
- Spoilers are allowed
- Non English articles should include a translation in the comments by deepl.com or similar
- Paywalled articles should include at least a brief summary in the comments, the wording of the article should not be altered
- Social media posts should be posted as screenshots with a link for those who want to view it
- Memes are allowed on Monday only as we all do like a laugh or 2, but donβt want to become formuladank.
Up next
2024 Calendar
| Location | Date |
|---|---|
| π¦πΏ Azerbaijan | 13-15 Sep |
| πΈπ¬ Singapore | 20-22 Sep |
| πΊπΈ United States | 18-20 Oct |
| π²π½ Mexico | 25-27 Oct |
| π§π· Brazil | 01-03 Nov |
| πΊπΈ United States | 21-23 Nov |
| πΆπ¦ Qatar | 29 Nov-01 Dec |
| π¦πͺ Abu Dhabi | 06-08 Dec |
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Yeah I'm scratching my head as to how this could happen. This isn't some 0.01 km/h over the pit speed limit "technically a penalty" type thing, 1.5kg is significant.
Almost seems like they forgot to install some ballist
It has to be the new floor, now that I think of it. They had the new floor on Friday, but it preformed poorly so they switched back to the old on Saturday. Maybe the new floor is 1.5kg heavier, and George's side of the garage forgot to adjust the ballast accordingly after they switched back?
Only thing I can think of.
Weren't they both running the new floor? That would mean that they both should be underweight?
I suspect they mucked up the driver ballast, minimum driver weight is 80kg, so if you weigh less than that the team have to add ballast. I've heard that they got the ballast the wrong way round between the two cars and Lewis weighs more so his ballast is less...
For some reason I thought George was tall enough to weigh about 80kg on his own, but it seems not.
Nah he weighs noticeably less than Lewis as Lewis has always been pretty stacked for a F1 driver and Lewis put on muscle when the weight limit went up
Not particularly a fan of Russell, but that was an inspired drive, and deserved win....rules are rules though...
an inspired drive that was probably possible because of the underweight car. 1,5 kg is significant and might have enabled him do a 1-stop.
Yeah, it's no wonder his tires were able to last so long
1.5kg, oof. That's more than the lap of picking up marbles would've given on other circuits. Just a mistake by the team. At least they pick up a win, but a blow to Russell and the team for sure.
Makes me wonder what the difference between a super used set of tires and a 30% used set of tires would be, though.
For sure, same! I think the whole assembly is 10-12 kg these days, only would need to lose ~400g additional per tire to be 1.5 under
Pirelli have said up to 1kg per tire, from new to fully used.
Tough but fair
So this is on Mercedes for miscalculating the weight and a DSQ is only fair.
However, this whole tyre weight and marble pickup thing seems so silly:
You pick up a different amount of marbles depending on track length (or no in-lap like in Spa), rain can wash them away, if you do a long stint your tyres have less rubber left on them. Tyres are standardized, identical between all teams for the whole season and Pirelli knows exactly how much they weigh brand new. After the race FIA could just weigh the car without wheels. I'm assuming right now teams are leaving a slight weight margin, so they would be able to run even closer to the limit if they didn't have to worry about tyre weight.
The fact is several other drivers did a one stop without running into the weight issue and in the past, we have had drivers do almost the whole race distance on a set of tyres after switching to a hard after an early safety car(lap 2 or 3). Never in those cases has the car been underweight. This is a cock up by Mercedes and nobody else.
Kinda explains how he managed the one stopperβ¦1.5kg is pretty significant
Does anybody know how much weight the tyres lose during a long stint like Russel did? And when compared to a 20-lap?
Definitely not 1.5 kgs worth.
That would be 400 grams per tire. Not an unreal number.
Why "definitely", please publish your info? Pirelli disagrees with you.
OK I found it myself : https://us.motorsport.com/f1/news/were-russells-worn-tyres-the-cause-of-his-spa-f1-disqualification/10640096/
βWe expect that the loss of rubber from the one-stop was a contributing factor, and we'll work to understand how it happened.
βWe won't be making any excuses though. It is clearly not good enough and we need to make sure it doesn't happen again.β
The missing weight of 1.5kg may sound like a lot, but we are only talking about 375 grammes from each corner.
And as Pirelli head of F1 Mario Isola has explained, that is well within the boundaries of how much a worn tyre loses.
No word on the specific cause that I've seen, just the team acknowledged that they made an error according to the release from the stewards. I'm not insinuating anything but I have to wonder how that happened and if it was isolated to just George's car.
It sucks, a sour end to an otherwise brilliant day for him and the team.
Could this be a factor in why Russell was able to do a 1stopper when everyone else couldn't? Because his car simply was so much lighter?
Others did do a 1-stop. Alonso and Tsunoda I believe. They weren't underweight.
I don't think the issue is the tyres, I think it was a cockup from the garage.
That would have vaulted him past Perez in the standings up to 7th.
It was a great drive by Russell and even bolder strategy call from him.
Mercedes fucked up big time. Now they have lost a lot of points and helped McLaren and Redbull get even further ahead in the standings.
Weird band name. Just ripping off Breaking Benjamin.