Stardew Valley

Penny was my first, before I knew I was also a woman. She is bookish and shy, and loves others and cares for children. She has a rough life at home, but still deeply cares for her mother.

She has a crush on Sam, but barely talks about it. She doesn't talk about much of anything, actually, until (!) you get to know her. Then she talks about everything on her mind so freely.

She likes to be alone with you. Her 10-heart scene is so sweet!!!

Also her spouse room is great! It's hard to not marry Penny every play through.

So yeah, Penny.

Haley. Because "Ew no"

Krobus, forever.

Penny. Every time.

I've never played this game before but my wife and daughter are both in love with this Harvey fellow who looks like Jim Gordon

Krobus and Abigail are great. Haley is also fine.

Leah was very disappointing.

I also married Leah first, but this playthrough I'm marrying Mary. I might marry Sebastian next

Set up a poll! That's what I did on my second playthrough. I surveyed Reddit and Maru won.

I want to say in my very first run when the game first came out it was Leah. These days I try and move in Krobus but my sibling always steals him first. So if I so marry anyone its like "hmmm let me pick at random". Last time was Abigail. A bit before it was Sebastian.

Penny was my default for several plays. I tried Abigail, but she was horribly rude to my character. I accidentally ended up with Leah who i liked a bit more than penny (something about how she is essentially a lifetime movie protagonist), but in the last save i went with Haley, and she really is as great as people say once you get a good relationship with her.

why does nobody like Abigail :( I love rock eating girl

My first spouse was Haley; mostly because she was the only one who wanted to dance with me on year 1.

My favourites are Abigail and then Maru. I can relate to the later better, but I love that free spirit vibe from Abby.

In my first playthrough, I was surprised to discover that I liked Haley the best. I probably would have gone with Krobus if he was an option at the time because I'll always go for the silly option when its available, but I didn't regret my pick either.