but am I just a buzz kill
Nah, I'm a longtime fan of absurd shit like Tim and Eric that is rooted heavily in a public television vibe of "doing things wrong and cheaply."
I was never sure if this was trying for a similar vibe or what, but I'm definitely one of the people who firmly never understood it.
I get a lot of hate for saying it, but this is how I feel about the creepy CGI baby from the otherwise top tier film Children of Men. It ruins an otherwise powerful scene for me.