DAE we're living in 1984?
Why do people act like 1984 was anything other than vibes based fiction?
this post was submitted on 13 Jul 2024
70 points (98.6% liked)
badposting
321 readers
265 users here now
badposting is a comm where you post badly
This is not a [email protected] alternative. This is not a [email protected] alternative. This is a place for you to post your bad posts.
Ever had a really shitty bit idea? Joke you want to take way past the point of where it was funny? Want to feel like a stand-up comedy guy who's been bombing a set for the past 30 minutes straight and at this point is just saying shit to see if people react to it? Really bad pun? A homemade cringe concoction? A cognitohazard that you have birthed into this world and have an urge to spread like chain mail?
Rules:
- Do not post good posts.
- Unauthorized goodposting is to be punished in the manner of commenting the phrase "GOOD post" followed by an emoji that has not yet been used in the thread
- Use an emoticon/kaomoji/rule-three-abiding ASCII art if the rations run out
- This is not a comm where you direct people to other people's bad posts. This is a comm where you post badly.
- This rule intentionally left blank.
- If you're struck for rule 3, skill issue, not allowed to complain about it.
Code of Conduct applies just as much here as it does everywhere else. Technically, CoC violations are bad posts. On the other hand: L + ratio + get ~~better~~ worse material bozo
founded 8 months ago
MODERATORS
it's funny because orwell was trying to throw shade on the USSR and only succeeded in describing england
i remember the half-truth going around when I was a teenager and first encountering this book, that orwell was actually writing about a system he himself was part of
it literally took until this thread for me to realise I still had never addressed that falsehood, like of course orwell didn't actually live in the USSR, but i bet most people (if asked) will still believe that to be the case - that 1984 is orwell criticising a system he previously supported/was a part of, and not a piece of fiction spun out of whole cloth
that 1984 is orwell criticising a system he previously supported/was a part of
Technically, I guess this is true if you interpret it as being a critique of 
. IIRC, there's nothing in the book indicating that Oceania is supposed to be a communist country, except maybe "Ingsoc", but you can easily dismiss that by saying the Nazis called themselves socialists too.
Yeah 1984 is a lot of things, but I never took it as anticommunist.
The anticommunist one is Animal farm.
They don't, their whole worldview is vibes based so it's perfectly coherent
Because anti-communism is a profitable business where you can just lie and make bank. That North Korean “defector” and all the articles written about China are examples.
I think I "studied" it 3 times in the Australian high school system (and Animal Farm)
i never like to attack orwell for being a cop, a snitch and a r*pist, but instead focus on the fact that the loser worked for the BBC and ASSUMED that the USSR would be worse and wrote a whole-ass book about his daydreaming.
working at the department of lies and propaganda sure feels like working for stalin's department of propaganda which i imagine is just like my actual job, which is evil, and therefore stalin and the whole soviet union is evil
deeply unserious person
God forbid people have fun.
The Taliban has entered the chat
Let people enjoy things (but unironically)
Orwell probably got bullied in grade school by a football stud
George Orwell was a resentful skinnyfat redditor.
Jorjor Well
I mean I am sure this was at least a novel observation at the time that admirably encouraged a less information rich society to think and learn more, but nowadays, and likely even back then, this complaint could serve as a snooty way for effette educated men to channel their lingering resentment toward having been excluded or bullied by the working class/popular kids at their secondary schools. It's a great line of self fellating cope for people bitter that they can't vibe or know the haps.
Someone blew my mind when they pointed out that Orwell was just writing what he knew, which was living in Britain.