it's conspicuous consumption as identity performance
this post was submitted on 21 Sep 2024
57 points (98.3% liked)
music
18506 readers
83 users here now
Post well known tunes into the megathread. Post fresh vibes individually.
🎵 Hexbear music streaming den 🎶
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
THANK YOU. coming from a place where it is endemic and now living in the NE I was very confused about the love my rehab roomie had for it until she told me all about her extensive cop and conservative family and it clicked. Everyone else up here that listens to it that I personally have met is the same, and it’s never the kind of stuff I don’t mind hearing either (George jones or Gary Stewart or Delbert McClinton or even some patty loveless or juice newton). It’s always the trucks n flags n eagles shit, kinda reinforces the point
It's not really conspicuous but yeah.
It can totally be conspicuous consumption. Have you ever tried to buy a new pair of cowboy boots? That shit is expensive. As is a lot of the other trappings of the genre/aesthetic like big trucks. Plus there's an entire subset of people who spend a ridiculous amount of money to look like they're dudes helping out on the family farm.
That's not a country only thing but it definitely rubs people the wrong way.
Basically. White reactionaries in the middle class actually spend a good deal of money just so they can LOOK like poor people. Personally, I like to call them "cosplay cowboys".
If you're a poor fool like me who's born in North America AND can't afford to live in megacities like NYC, Montreal, Toronto, LA, etc. You know what I'm talking about.
Country music is not conspicuous. Which is the topic here.
I think the culture surrounding music is relevant when discussing it but even if we want to stick only to the actual music: steel guitars are super expensive and the lyrical themes of many country songs involve lifestyles most working class people are priced out of.
It is when its being played in public
Go ahead and add the Midwest to that too.
:(
You're right though, so many people here think they're rugged country men while listening to a pop music with fake southern accents by people that grew up in rich suburbs.
Growing up I had to listen to Toby Keith singing about putting a boot up Bin Laden's ass so many times it's permanently burned into my brain even though I lived north of the Mason-Dixon at the time.
It's the obsession with Americana
I just got back from the state fair and it's all Cowboy hats and leather jackets
Like, just because you have a F-150 you take to Whole Foods and a horse you keep in a stable five towns over, that don't make you a country boy
I went to suburban (read rich) Connecticut once, and ya that shit was everywhere.
I was eating Korean food for lunch today at a new restaurant and the food was really good but they were playing that basic, country-esque White people music and it was terrible. I was like "Why, God?”
It became one of the default "not of the city" music genres. It became the background noise of white people.
also: shut up about your fuckin jeep
Coming from the (non-coastal) Southwest with midwestern parents, I fucking hate country music with every fiber of my being.
This is Sturgill Simpson erasure.
Sturgill Simpson just woke up one morning and decided to make like 5 new genres of music.
Wife truck dog beer gun gas
A.I.
Sure, I'd be happy to help create a song using those words. Here's a short verse:
In the cab of that wife's truck, under the prairie sky so wide,
With our loyal dog beside us, joy and love, our only guide.
We raise a can of frothy beer, to life, to love, to freedom's song,
In this moment, we're the toughest, with our trusty gun, we're strong.
Fueled by gas and boundless dreams, we ride, two souls as one.
My high school band wrote a country song called "dead dog in a pick up truck" that talked about how my wife left me so we could audition to play at a local bar (which looking back was super sketchy to allow us in to begin with.)
Surely the northeast should be listening to Folk and Maritime.
I always hated country music but got into it with Johnny Cashs American Recordings and after watching Ken Burns documentation "Country Music" I am even more open to it. It is a kind of grassroot music, music of the people.
something something white cultural identification something
edit: I mean this seriously, I just can't remember what the exact terminology is for "participating in this [country music] culture as a way of reaffirming whiteness and the status quo that comes with it" 
idk, why do people constantly have to post about how much they hate country music?
Bc it sucks and there are entire parts of the country where it's shoved down your throat.
Never been to Tennessee but I guess that's all they play there. The radio stations are all country, talk shows, or gospel. No hip hop, rock, R&B, jazz...nothing. Person I knew was telling me about it, but maybe things have changed in the last 15ish years.
I grew up in MO and where i lived we could get 4 different country stations and a pop station (that also played a bunch of country.) it wasn't until my senior year of high school where you could get a rock station, which was actually cool bc they had a couple college kid DJs that played some cool stuff.
I wouldn't have listened to any hip hop, R&B, jazz or punk without the internet. my family side eyes me if I happen to listen to any of those genres when I'm back home.
it's pretty much everywhere.. especially anywhere not near a city of a million+
because it takes longer to say that I hate a certain predominant type of country music that is overwhelmingly the most likely to be heard in any public space or around almost anyone who “loves country” who isn’t a music head or a comrade. Like that’s a long ass sentence
Nickelback (or the contemporary equivalent) is terrible and ubiquitous, but you don't see people saying "fuck, I hate rock music" without qualification.
There is no contemporary equivalent to Nickelback bc rock music isn't really relevant that much anymore but I've heard people go out of their way to say they hate metal, jazz, hip hop, pop music, EDM, and disco without qualification plenty of times.
Not even saying I hate it, it’s pretty neutral to me, I just don’t get why it has such a hold on people not from the country or the south or rural areas.
For a while when clear channel was taking over big time, the only good radio stations up north were country.
So if you spent time driving around listening to the radio then you like country music.
I'm guessing it's not the good sort of country like Townes Van Zandt or Chris Stapleton.
Classic country is where it’s at
If you’ve ever played gta San Andreas, don’t tell me you didn’t absolutely fuck with k rose
just start tricking them into listening to the cool country thats about doing drugs and committing crimes
White people love their damn country music.
A whole genre about how Hitler was the coolest thing ever, but with generous verses about how pollution, burning crosses in klan robes, swastikas and violence makes you a badass? That sums up the white psyche almost perfectly.
pre 9-11 country music is actually good